Statement by Socialist Alternative
Burnham’s speech on the steps of Downing street struck a note of optimism and renewal. He claims to offer the biggest political change in forty years. That’s a significant number to choose. With it, Burnham is suggesting that he will decisively end the politics of neoliberalism and austerity. Since the 1980s, these have brought about an unprecedented transfer of wealth from the working class to the capitalists. So Burnham’s pledge to break with this will surely sound like positive news for millions.
But, as always, the question is: can he deliver on the hopes and expectations he is raising? Will he actually turn living standards around? Crucially, is he prepared to take on the incredibly powerful vested interests of the super-rich capitalist class and take the wealth which exists to transform life for millions out of the hands of the billionaires and put it to work for people’s needs?
Burnham talks about achieving greater ‘public control’ of some important sections of the economy. This language is deliberately vague. The truth is you can’t control what you don’t own. That’s why what’s really needed – as an absolute minimum starting point – is the immediate renationalisation of water, energy and mail, as well as kicking the privateers out of the NHS. This should be done without using public money to compensate those who have enriched themselves by polluting our rivers, hiking prices in an energy crisis, closing post offices, or ripping off our health service.
Many will be encouraged by Burnham’s pledge to end rough sleeping. But to do so requires a massive investment in council house building, the confiscation of vacant investment properties, stringent private sector rent controls and a massive injection of new resources into mental health, drug and addiction services. It is also an aim which is fundamentally incompatible with the Labour right’s desire to further restrict access to benefits and cut welfare to fund the military. Indeed, the detail already released about this policy suggest the extra money being pledged for is just £340 million taken from ‘unused’ parts of the existing housing budget and 1,200 new homes – surely nowhere near enough to fix this problem. This underlines that delivering on a popular promise like this is far from straight forward for a politician who has been anxious to reassure the capitalists that he will be (in their eyes) ‘fiscally responsible’.
We know much of the team Burnham has around him has worked in previous right-wing anti-working class governments. In fact, Burnham himself has done so in the past. This speaks to the importance of the workers’ movement refusing to offer any blank cheques to this new Prime Minister. In fact – quite the opposite – we need to be preparing for an autumn of strikes and protests to demand proper, above inflation pay rises across the board and to fight for full funding of our public services.
We need to continue to build the fight against war and imperialism. Burnham went out of his way to make mention of fulfilling Britain’s ‘international commitments’ on military spending. And while he has attempted to distance himself from Starmer’s approach on Palestine, he has conspicuously failed to acknowledge that the people of Gaza have faced genocide at the hands of the Israeli state.
An early test for Burnham will be whether he translates these words into action and finally ends British support for the genocidal IDF, as well as if he will be prepared to reverse draconian anti-protest laws such as the ban on Palestine Action. Again, so far the indications on this are far from positive.
Burnham is not a carbon copy of Starmer. He clearly understands that the British political establishment is living on borrowed time and there is a mass appetite for radical change. But in the context of a decaying and declining British capitalism, actually delivering for working-class people would require a major confrontation with the ruling class.
This is a problem for a man who comes to power basically suggesting that he can straddle the diametrically opposed interests of workers and the capitalists. In this equation, unless working-class people are able to apply huge pressure through mass, unified and escalating action, it will be the interests of the capitalists which ultimately win out.
This means we need to start organising now to fight for the radical socialist change millions of people are looking for. That means organising in our workplaces, universities, schools and colleges. It means being prepared to challenge divisive racism and the danger of the far right. And it means building around socialist ideas.
Capitalism is a system which offers a future of war, poverty and environmental destruction. Burnham today tried to tap into the desire millions have for something better. But the truth is, this requires fundamental, revolutionary change – a break with capitalism. Burnham does not offer this. It is up to working-class people to fight for it.











