We are approaching what is likely to be one of the most consequential sets of elections in recent British history, without any Westminster seats up for grabs. A great deal is on the line.
Editorial from issue 64 of Socialist Alternative’s monthly newspaper. Subscribe today!
Starmer is hanging by a thread, and the political map that has existed for a century is being ripped up and re-drawn. Indeed, when we wake up on 8 May, we will surely find it to have been altered in profound new ways.
This is a major test for all significant political forces across England, Wales and Scotland. There are more than 5,000 councillors facing election across 136 councils in England. This includes major contests in most big cities. Meanwhile, all 129 seats of the Scottish parliament are up for grabs for the first time in five years. The make up of the newly-expanded Welsh Assembly will also be determined. And mayoral contests will take place across five London boroughs, as well as in Watford.
Labour crisis
Whatever happens over the next several weeks of campaigning, it’s clear that Labour will lose seats across the board. The party’s calamitous polling, along with the Tories, is the richly deserved consequence of its disastrous record in government.
These elections take place against a background of war, turmoil and a dramatically intensifying cost-of-living crisis. Starmer has thrown his lot in with Trump and Netanyahu, allowing British military bases to be used in an imperialist adventure that will cost tens of thousands of lives and send prices skyrocketing.
Back at home, Labour has viciously turned on the most vulnerable in our society, aping the far-right policies of Reform when it comes to immigration and attacking welfare. Meanwhile, the rottenness and moral depravity of Blairism – Starmer’s political tradition – has been exposed in the Epstein files, especially via the Mandelson scandal. The Prime Minister is absolutely up to his neck in it.
For all these reasons and more, the question is not will this be a bad day for Labour, but how bad? The scale of the catastrophe the party faces, and to whom most seats are lost, will be decisive in determining what comes next. All the signs currently point to Starmer being forced out rapidly following these elections. But there is also a possibility he clings on, weakened. If so, this would probably only last until rivals like Angela Rayner or Andy Burnham feel better positioned to mount a leadership challenge.
It will be particularly devastating for Labour if many or most of the seats the party loses are won by political forces positioning themselves to the party’s left. Reform certainly stands to make gains whatever happens. But Starmer’s best hope for this election, and for Labour’s future, is to try and establish a narrative of this being a choice between him or Farage. For that reason, a stronger result for Reform is preferable for him. Should they underperform, this can create a sense of stalled momentum, which has already been a feature of the situation over recent months.
The recent Gorton and Denton by-election exposed the ‘Labour vs. Reform’ myth as a lie. There, Labour were beaten into third place and the Green Party emerged as a credible alternative, much more capable of winning against the right than anyone associated with our deeply unpopular government.
Green surge?
May’s elections will be the first opportunity since Zack Polanski became the party’s new leader for the Greens to make substantial electoral headway in nationally-held polls. The Green Party has the wind in its sails. Polanski’s bold anti-austerity rhetoric taps into the enormous class anger that has been building in society for years. His party’s victory in the Gorton and Denton by-election has shown voting Green can be a viable strategy for defeating the right. The fact that the council elections are concentrated in major metropolitan areas creates even more potential for there to be an important electoral breakthrough for the Greens.
Meanwhile in Wales, the main nationalist party Plaid Cymru is projected to become the largest party in the Welsh assembly for the first time. This would be a seismic victory for Plaid and a crushing blow for Labour, which has been the dominant political force in Wales for more than 100 years. In Scotland, despite the SNP having been mired in scandal and crisis over the recent period, polling suggests a significant pro-independence majority will still be returned to the Scottish parliament following these elections. This will be a substantial setback for Scottish Labour despite its partial recovery at the 2024 general election.
Your Party
But conspicuously absent from capitalist media discussions about these elections is Your Party (YP). YP was launched by Jeremy Corbyn and Zarah Sultana last year, with enormous initial enthusiasm. Socialist Alternative has been part of fighting to establish the party in every area of the country we have a presence. Impressive and dynamic branches have been organised in many areas. But they have had to do this work in spite of a complete absence of leadership and support from the Corbyn-controlled HQ.
This is a crying shame. Were YP HQ to support its hundreds of members who want to or will stand in these elections, it would be able to offer something truly unique. Among political parties with a national profile, YP alone has a clear position of opposing all cuts to jobs and services. At its conference last November, it passed a policy committing it to supporting needs-based people’s budgets, as well as using council positions to mount a mass struggle to demand the funding necessary for local communities.
By contrast, the Green Party nationally (along with Zack Polanski personally) has ruled out working outside of the budgetary constraints imposed on councils by Westminster. In practice, this points to the Green Party becoming the widespread enforcers of austerity in local government – a role they have already played in cities including Bristol and Brighton.
YP is also unique in that its members include many of the most dynamic class fighters in our society. In YP proto-branches around the country, many of these same fighters will be standing in the May elections, despite the absence of support from HQ. In most areas, they will be forced to do so under different electoral names.
Scandalously, although YP Scotland voted by a clear majority to stand candidates in the Holyrood elections at its conference, it currently looks like this will not be facilitated by HQ. This is despite a huge opportunity existing for a socialist political force there. The various nationalist forces are in crisis and the Scottish Greens participated in a national austerity-enforcing government with the SNP between 2021 and 2024.
Socialist Alternative members standing
Socialist Alternative members will be taking part in election campaigns via many of the YP branches we take part in. In East London, Connor Rosoman will be standing under the name Waltham Forest Independent Socialists, alongside another member of the Leyton and Wansted YP proto-branch, Susan Catten. In Kirklees, Mike Forster, who has played a pioneering role in establishing YP in the Yorkshire region, will be standing under the name of the People’s Alliance for Change and Equality. In Salford, Hugh Caffrey and Jacob Allen will be standing as part of a city-wide Your Party challenge mounted by the local proto-branch.
These are campaigns which we intend to use – to help build the fightback, but also develop and grow the YP branches and networks that have been established. In that sense, these will not be purely electoral challenges. They will be about reaching out to and helping to organise working-class people to fight for a socialist alternative to war and austerity.
The campaigns will not be restricted to routine door-to-door leafleting (though this will be done). There will also be mega-canvasses, campaign stalls, rallies and public meetings.
The urgent need for the political re-organisation of working-class people has not gone away because of the problems at the top of YP.
Capitalism is a system which offers us and our children a bleak and dangerous future of war, poverty and environmental destruction. But we live in a world rich in resources – one in which the technology and expertise exists to solve all of these problems. The prime barrier to humanity doing so is the existence of a global economic system in which the needs of private profit, not people, are the fundamental driving force.
Socialist Alternative is an organisation which stands for the complete re-organisation of society to put working-class people in control. We are fighting to build broader political forces – like YP – which can begin to re-organise workers and within which socialist ideas can be debated, discussed and honed. But we are also clear about the need to urgently develop revolutionary forces in Britain and internationally – forces which are clear about what is needed to change the world.
Socialist Alternative fights for a complete transformation of society, based on nationalising the biggest monopolies that dominate our economy under democratic working-class control, and democratically planning production to meet human need. We are part of an international organisation, ISA, which is part of trying to develop and build revolutionary socialist organisations around the world. If you agree with the need for a force like this, join us.











