The outcome of the Central Executive Committee (CEC) elections, announced at the end of February, has come as a disappointment to many of the socialists active in Your Party (YP).
By Mike Forster
There were two main factions fighting for the leadership of YP, organised under the names ‘Grassroots Left’ and ‘The Many’. Socialist Alternative backed the slate of the Grassroots Left, supported by Zarah Sultana, which was ultimately unsuccessful in winning a majority.
The 24-member CEC is now controlled by The Many faction, with the Grassroots Left able to muster around 9 votes for their platform. The Many’s victory was achieved by leveraging the advantage of control over the party’s apparatus, data and finances, often in a deeply inappropriate manner. Instead of positive political proposals to “get the party back on track”, The Many flooded members’ inboxes with increasingly alarmist and manipulative appeals for support, alleging the need to “defend Jeremy” against supposed “abuse”. Even worse, throughout the campaign, they threatened not-so-implicitly to walk away if results did not go in their favour.
‘The Many’ control of CEC
The first meetings of the CEC have clearly shown the direction they now want to take and confirmed some of our worst fears. The Many have used their majority to introduce CEC agendas restricted to just two hours on a Sunday afternoon, along with electing an Officers Group which will meet weekly to decide on most important issues affecting YP’s future. This group reports to the CEC at its meetings and their reports have so far been rubber stamped by The Many’s representatives.
This has unfortunately reinforced a model of organisation running contrary to what is obviously necessary. This is a top-down model in which great power is given to unnamed staff who will determine the agenda and remit of the Officers Group, which in turn can expect all its decisions to be ratified by a compliant and submissive CEC. Every proposals put forward by the Grassroots Left has so far been ruthlessly voted down (or not even heard), with little to no debate. This represents a big setback for those who were hoping and campaigning for an open, democratic party based on its branches and members.
Major issues unaddressed
The major and immediate issues facing YP were not properly addressed – namely the Together Alliance demo on 28 March, branch formation, the local elections in England, and the Assembly elections in Scotland and Wales. Candidates wanting to stand for YP have been advised to apply for nomination, which will not be ratified by the Officers Group until 30 March. Since the elections will be taking place on 7th May, this will be too late for many candidates who have already begun their campaign work. So virtually all the YP supporting election candidates will be standing under independent or local banners rather than the name YP!
Grassroots Left CEC member Mel Mullings from London recently led the call for a YP contingent on the 28 March demo – something Socialist Alternative has also been calling for. This was enthusiastically taken up by the London region of YP proto-branches, being widely advertised through informal rank-and-file networks. In other words, local proto-branches took the bull by the horns and got on with the urgent task of building these branches. But this was despite, not because of, the YP leadership. In fact, the CEC did not get round to discussing the march until a week before it took place! The huge turnout on 28 March showed exactly what is possible and should give confidence to all working-class people fighting back, including in YP.
The big turnout and important YP bloc has sent a clear signal to members who now have to fight to keep organised and continue building vibrant local branches. We must demand our branches are recognised without delay with the resources to carry out their work, including access to local membership data. But unfortunately, rather than this being an automatic process, it will require the exertion of organised pressure from below on the CEC. Indeed, the CEC is currently giving the very clear impression that it will take a long time for branches to be recognised and ratified. But this is time that is not on our side!
The huge potential of YP has been tragically undermined by the unelected clique which has been running things from the centre since the party was launched last July. From the dizzying highpoint of 800,000 registered supporters last year, the official membership, we were told, is now 60,000. This is a disappointing decline for which the current leadership must take full responsibility.
Working-class party vitally needed
The working class has been crying out for a new socialist party rooted in struggle as capitalism has piled on all the ills of its crises onto our shoulders. Starmer has utterly betrayed the hopes of millions for change. Last year, YP was poised to make the decisive breakthrough with the announcement that Zarah Sultana and Jeremy Corbyn would co-lead the founding of such a party. The goodwill and excitement generated by that announcement was squandered by inexcusable delays, infighting and hostile briefings in the capitalist media.
Tragically, the unelected clique around Jeremy Corbyn deliberately isolated and publicly briefed against Zarah Sultana, including threats of legal action. This has alienated many of the sign-ups and left YP looking increasingly like a Labour 2.0 – mimicking some of the worst anti-democratic practices of that party.
Meanwhile the victory of the Greens in the Gorton, and Denton by-election, led by Zack Polanski, has resulted in a membership surge of over 220,000 members. The Greens themselves report that a large number of ‘Corbynistas’ have now joined their branches and are causing some friction. Meanwhile YP’s standing in opinion polls has all but disappeared from an earlier prediction of up to 18% last year.
What next?
This has left many pondering ‘what next for YP?’ Socialist Alternative has been advocating from the outset that YP had to turn out into local struggles, build strong community and working-class based support to make the idea of a new democratic socialist party a reality. This task is now more urgent than ever. Our members are undertaking that task in local proto-branches, whether organised under the name YP or other local networks, whilst also arguing for that approach in Grassroots Left supporters groups.
Currently, YP remains in flux, with a very unequal spread of activities. There are over 100 branches organised under the loose banner of YP. Some are undertaking very good work, others are unsure about next steps, and some are in the doldrums. The task of building a new working-class party will not be straightforward. It will require patience and determination.
It is now crucial that rank and file branches are brought together in a national conference to hammer out and decide on the next steps, to give confidence to local activists and a clear sense of direction to branches. It would make most sense that this be organised by the Your Party Connections group, which already brings together huge numbers of branches. This would have the potential to call such a conference and chart a socialist way forward.











