Former Tory senior advisor: Scotland “is not a country”

By Matt Hirst, Socialist Alternative West Yorkshire

Henry Newman, former senior advisor to Michael Gove, when he was Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities, angered many during the general election period when he claimed that Scotland wasn’t a country, but merely a ‘region’ of the UK.

His out-of-touch comments, made on BBC Politics Live, show a complete lack of understanding: not just of the thirst for independence of millions in Scotland, but also of basic geography! Or perhaps it was intentional, with successive Tory governments, and now Starmer’s Labour government, all putting the ‘integrity of the union’ above the wishes of Scottish workers, in the vainglorious attempt to project Britain as a world power.

Some may argue that the dramatic collapse of the SNP in the recent General Election, with a loss of 39 Westminster seats in Scotland to Labour and the Liberal Democrats, would indicate a dramatic drop in support for Scottish independence. Even the Westminster Leader of the SNP, Stephen Flynn, has been claiming that independence is a ‘hard sell’.

However this superficial understanding of the forces at play, both for independence, and in the way that people voted in this general election, completely misunderstands the situation. Whilst Labour were able to win most of the seats lost by the SNP, this was not a renunciation of Scottish independence, but instead a conscious act by Scottish people to get rid of the Tories from Westminster, and they saw Labour as being the best chance to do that.

Also, after over a decade of the SNP being the largest Westminster party in Scotland, many Scottish people felt underwhelmed at the SNP’s inability to actually achieve independence for Scotland, instead making pleas to Westminster to allow a new referendum. Attempts to appeal to the Supreme Court in 2022 to grant Scotland the right of a new referendum was merely to drive the mood for independence down a dead end – the courts are an arm of the state; there to uphold the state’s rule and protect its interests, and has no interest in the desire of Scottish workers and youth.

Collapse in SNP does not mean collapse for independence support

A recent poll, taken just before the General Election by Statista, shows support for Scottish independence currently sitting at 47%. Whilst this is not currently a majority for independence, this is again reflective of the SNP’s inability to take the independence movement forward. On top of this the allegations of corruption in the SNP, and their unwillingness to oppose cuts determined by Westminster, has led to elements of the Scottish working class without a hope for independence.

The only way that Scotland can fight for independence is through struggle, and not on an electoral basis. It must be a struggle in the workplaces, campuses and on the streets. The movements of workers on strike, LGBTQ+ people, climate campaigners and all those fighting to end the brutality and oppression of capitalism need to be drawn together to build a working-class party of mass struggle.

Socialist Alternative is calling for national and regional conferences of resistance to begin to bring together all these struggles under one banner, and we will enthusiastically take part in these, arguing not just for independence for Scotland now, but for a socialist transformation of society, made up of a voluntary socialist federation of Scotland, Ireland, Wales and England.

Share
Facebook
Twitter

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *